• Home
  • Advice
  • Brands
  • Partners
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Forum
  • New car ratings

Our all-new and unique Expert Rating system analyses new cars based on dozens of UK media reviews to give you the best possible car buying advice. Check it out now!

New car review

Alfa Romeo Stelvio review

Does Alfa Romeo’s first SUV match rivals in the market while retaining that evocative Italian DNA?

Would you like to be kept up to date with the latest from The Car Expert?

Design
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Driving experience
8.0
Value for money
8.0
Safety
9.0

Summary

Minor irritations apart, the Alfa Romeo Stelvio is an effective new entrant to the SUV market. It is generally well built, and offers a combination of attractive looks and sporting prowess that many rivals do not.

Summary

Minor irritations apart, the Alfa Romeo Stelvio is an effective new entrant to the SUV market. It is generally well built, and offers a combination of attractive looks and sporting prowess that many rivals do not.
 

Inside the Alfa Romeo Stelvio

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The Stelvio sits around 20cm higher off the ground than a Giulia which makes getting into it pretty easy, and once inside anyone who has sat in the Alfa saloon will find this car’s surroundings highly familiar.

The Giulia’s insides have effectively been transplanted straight into the Stelvio, and this is a good thing as the layout is well thought-out and the finish solid. Having said that, the inlays and trim of our test car did not exactly scream ‘premium’ in the manner of some of its rivals.

Where the disparity shows most is in the infotainment system. Yes, the Alfa Connect unit is present with all its bells and whistles, but it does not come close to rivals with its small display screen and somewhat last-generation graphics.

A selling point for the Stelvio is its not-that-SUV-like profile, so one expects a compromise in interior space. Actually it’s perfectly adequate, with enough room in the back for adults of reasonable height. At 525 litres boot space is adequate too, the luggage bay nice and flat and easily accessed through the electrically operated tailgate. It’s not very wide, however, and there’s no useful underfloor space to hide valuables in.

Driving the Alfa Romeo Stelvio

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The brief to the Alfa engineers creating the Stelvio was to make it drive as much like a Giulia as possible. Notable steps towards that aim include serious weight saving – aluminium is used extensively, from the engine block to various panels, and the car even boasts a propshaft made from carbon fibre.

As a result, one revels in performance that is enthusiastic in a way SUVs just shouldn’t be. But it is enthusiasm without insistence – the car performs without making it obvious.

Our test car may be fitted with the most powerful engine option, but under acceleration it does not feel anywhere near as rushed as the increase in speed signifies. The engine note is hushed, perhaps too much so for a product from a brand with such a sporty image.

The transmission slickly shifts up through its eight speeds, though if one switches from Normal to the Dynamic driving mode it will hold onto a ratio right up to the rev limit – yet this is set well before the engine note could become significant.

 
 

The Alfa AWD transmission is a smart unit, with all torque to the rear in normal driving but able to divert 50% of the grip up front when conditions demand. And this contributes to what is a very good chassis – again Giulia inspired.

The double wishbone front, multi-link rear setup (the latter a new design patented by Alfa Romeo) makes for impressive handling prowess – the steering responds sharply to the touch, producing inch-perfect cornering even at speed, while the body remains obstinately upright. It’s so precise, so instantly responsive that some occupants may be slightly unnverved.

Cruising a motorway at close to the limit, the Stelvio remains well-behaved, ready to dial in the potency when needed but not making this ability at all obvious until it is needed.

It’s a pity that such an accomplished car on the road sheds some of the lustre from its performance courtesy of those irritations that Alfa Romeo owners are used to – odd dash notifications, confusing menus and little glitches that for too long have been justified by the phrase “Well it’s an Alfa.”

For this reviewer such oddities were summed up by the start stop system on our test car. In rain, with the wipers going, the system would cut the engine at junctions as it should, and then as it restarted cause the wipers to pause momentarily in their progress across the screen. Why? Other cars don’t do that, and after a while it becomes highly irritating…

Summary

Minor irritations apart, the Alfa Romeo Stelvio is an effective new entrant to the crowded SUV market. It is generally well built, while crucially it offers a combination of attractive looks and sporting prowess that many rivals do not.

Traditionally Alfa Romeo owners have been fiercely loyal to the brand, insisting the image justifies the irritations that have been just as traditional a part of Alfa Romeo ownership.

The Stelvio retains some of these irritations, but not too many, but it also offers that rare quality in the Alfa image – it really is a sporty SUV.

Key specifications

Make & model Alfa Romeo Stelvio BMW X3 Porsche Macan
Specification 2.0 turbo Petrol Q4 AWD Milano Edizione xDrive20i M Sport Macan S
Price (on-road) £45,390 £42,370 £45,917
Engine 2.0-litre petrol 2.0-litre petrol 2.0-litre petrol
Power 280 hp 184 hp 252 hp
Torque 400 Nm 290 hp 370 Nm
0-62mph 5.7 sec 8.3 sec 6.7 sec
Top speed 143 mph 134 mph 142 mph
Fuel economy (combined) 40.4 mpg 38.7 mpg 38.7 mpg
CO2 emissions 161 g/km 166 g/km 171 g/km
Insurance group 36E 31E 45E
Euro NCAP rating 5 stars (2017) 5 stars (2017) 5 stars (2014)

 

Design
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Driving experience
8.0
Value for money
8.0
Safety
9.0

Summary

Minor irritations apart, the Alfa Romeo Stelvio is an effective new entrant to the SUV market. It is generally well built, and offers a combination of attractive looks and sporting prowess that many rivals do not.
Andrew Charman
Andrew Charman
Andrew is the News and Road Test Editor for The Car Expert. He is a member of the Guild of Motoring Writers, and has been testing and writing about new cars for more than 20 years. Today he is well known to senior personnel at the major car manufacturers and attends many new model launches each year.

What are your thoughts? Let us know below.

The Car Expert Gold Partners

(click each logo to read more)

Alfa Romeo Stelvio review 1
Alfa Romeo Stelvio review 2
Alfa Romeo Stelvio review 3
Alfa Romeo Stelvio review 4

Latest new car reviews

Jaguar XE test drive

The Jaguar XE has undergone a mid-life revamp that ticks boxes on all fronts. Jaguar has clearly listened to complaints and set out to answer its critics.

Mercedes-Benz GLE test drive

The new Mercedes-Benz GLE is longer and wider than before, but what's it like to live with?

Triple Test: Toyota Supra vs Porsche 718 Cayman T vs Alpine A110

We put three of the best new sports car together for a triple test: the Toyota Supra, Porsche 718 Cayman T and Alpine A110 face off. Who comes out on top?

Morgan Plus 4 110 Works Edition test drive

As far as birthday presents go, the Morgan Plus 4 110 Works Edition is right up there, and the additional extras you get strengthen it as an overall prospect.