Independent, impartial advice for car buyers and car owners

Find an Expert Rating: 

Budget tyres vs premium tyres

Do budget tyres represent better value for money than premium tyres? We help explain what you should look for

Our Expert Partners

Looking for car tyres? Check out the latest offers from our commercial partners below.
MotorEasy logo 300x150

Tyres, warranty, GAP and servicing from MotorEasy
Find out more

Kwik Fit logo

For tyres, brakes, MOT, exhausts and car services you can trust
Find out more

ebay logo 600x300

Shop car tyres with installation
Find out more

Tyre Shopper logo 360x180px

The UK's No. 1 online cheap tyre retailer – guaranteed
Find out more

Tyre Pros logo 2022

Cheap tyres in your local area
Find out more

My Tyres logo 392x196px

Europe’s biggest online tyre retailer
Find out more


If you have ever phoned a tyre fitter to enquire about the cost of replacement tyres for your vehicle, you will know that there is a huge range of tyres available for virtually any car – from world-renowned premium brands at premium prices, to wide choice of mid-range tyres, to budget tyres from brands that you’ve probably never heard of.

Consequently, choosing the right tyre for your car and for the mileage and conditions in which you drive can be a confusing business. And with a huge differential in terms of the price of premium and budget tyres, often the temptation is to aim for value without giving consideration to whether premium tyres are worth their weight in… well, rubber.

Premium branded tyres

For premium tyres think Goodyear, Michelin, Pirelli, Bridgestone et al. These are the tyres that, although black and round like their cheaper counterparts, will deflate your bank account faster than your last blowout.

But by purchasing a premium tyre, you are also paying for the huge sums invested in tyre technology, engineering and safety testing that goes into making these tyres both hard-wearing and safe.

In product tests carried out by car magazine What Car?, premium brands consistently outperformed their cheaper rivals, offering improved wear, grip and fuel efficiency. If you tend to cover many miles each year or engage in a lot of high speed driving such as on motorways, then these tyres could be well worth shelling out a little extra for.

Mid-range brands

Sandwiched between the upper and lower echelons of the tyre market are the mid-range brands, which tend to sport familiar premium brand names or are often manufactured by these companies under a different name.

These tyres are often a good compromise for general use, offering more in the way of wear and fuel efficiency than the cheapest alternatives and benefiting from the same technology invested in the premium brands, but at a more reasonable price.

Budget tyres

The key question concerning budget tyres is whether you get what you pay for and whether buying cheaper tyres is actually economical in the long run. The answer is a confusing “possibly”.

These tyres, which are more suited for slower speeds on urban roads or for cars that only do low mileage, are more appropriate for second cars or ‘runarounds’ where distance isn’t an issue.

Of course, if cost is a serious consideration, a budget tyre is a preferable option to a more expensive tyre that is badly worn or distorted. Essentially budget tyres offer good value so long as you don’t expect to complete a tour from Land’s End to John O’Groats.

Improved labelling

With EU requirements now in force for tyre manufacturers to provide clear performance labelling on tyres, consumers are able to make a more reasoned judgement about the tyres that are most suited to their vehicle, their journeys and their style of driving.

Are budget tyres better value than premium tyres? Find out at TheCarExpert.co.uk

Latest car tyre features and advice