Crash test cars earn five-star ratings

- Advertisement -

Top five-star ratings have proven the norm in the latest series of crash tests of new models staged by Euro NCAP.

Of the nine cars tested by the safety body, just one, the Citroën E-Mehari, failed to achieve the five-star score. The retro-styled electric buggy, which is not sold in the UK, could only manage three stars.

The tested models included four new to the market in 2017 – the E-Mehari, the Jaguar E-Pace and DS 7 Crossback SUVs, and Mercedes-Benz’s first pickup model, the X-Class.

Also tested were the latest versions of the BMW X3, Subaru XV and Subaru Impreza, while the Honda Civic was retested following improvements to its rear seat restraints and side curtain airbags that had seen the car achieve only four stars in its first test earlier in the year.

- Advertisement -

A lack of driver-assistance systems doomed the Citroën E-Mehari to three stars.

E-Mehari ‘satisfactory’

The e-Mehari is sold widely in Europe and could, for example, be offered to UK holidaymakers as a hire car. According to Euro NCAP, its crash protection was satisfactory, with standard airbags and seatbelt load-limiters and pre-tensioners, the e-Mehari offers satisfactory crash protection but its star rating was held back due to the stripped-back open car not including driver-assistance systems that are the norm in other vehicles – including the DS 7 produced by Citroën’s sister brand.

Matthew Avery, head of research at Euro NCAP’s UK body Thatcham Research, described the results as a strong showing for the vehicle manufacturers who submitted cars for testing, and praised the widespread of autonomous emergency braking. “It is encouraging that drivers of all eight cars will be supported by standard-fit AEB – a technology which is proven to reduce accidents –  as two cars aimed at the family market, the Honda Civic and the Subaru Impreza’s suite of safety technologies are especially welcome,” Avery said.

Euro NCAP secretary general Michiel van Ratingen admitted that the five-star results would be unsurprising to some, but continue to represent outstanding engineering achievements.

“(A five-star rating) should not be taken for granted given the fact that Euro NCAP’s rating regime now includes over 15 different tests and hundreds of individual requirements, which are strengthened all the time – it is very positive that manufacturers still see a five-star rating as the target for most new vehicle models,” van Ratingen added.

Evidence of the challenges facing manufacturers is evident in new tests that Euro NCAP intends to introduce in 2018, in which brake systems that can detect and mitigate cyclists will be put to the test for the first time.

“These new tests and other planned updates will reflect the surge in automated vehicle functions that we expect to see on the market in the next years – our mission is to help consumers understand how these systems operate, to show what they are capable of and to explain how one day these might save your life,” van Ratingen said.

DS 7 Crossback The Car Expert
The flagship DS7 Crossback was among the five-star performers.

- Advertisement -
Andrew Charman
Andrew Charman
Andrew is a road test editor for The Car Expert. He is a member of the Guild of Motoring Writers, and has been testing and writing about new cars for more than 20 years. Today he is well known to senior personnel at the major car manufacturers and attends many new model launches each year.

Latest Expert Advice

Personal Contract Purchase: the PCP explained

The PCP (personal contract purchase) is the most popular type of car finance. This guide tells you everything you need to know about PCP car finance.

Car insurance providers cut coverage for misfuelling drivers

The number of car insurance providers refusing to cover damage caused by drivers putting the wrong fuel in their cars has increased considerably.

Latest Expert Ratings

Audi A4

Based on nearly 50 reviews, the Audi A4 has an Expert Rating that matches the Mercedes-Benz C-Class but falls some way behind the BMW 3 Series and others.

BMW X5

The BMW X5 currently holds a rating of 80% on our Expert Rating scale, which is a few points behind the class leaders but still competitive.

Limited-edition Cupra Ateca bolsters line-up

Cupra has announced a limited-edition version of its not-a-SEAT Ateca performance SUV.

Refreshed Mitsubishi Mirage arrives in UK

The revised Mitsubishi Mirage is now available in the UK, with pricing starting at £10,550.

UK used car market holds steady in 2019

Some 7.9 million used cars changed hands during the year, almost exactly the same as the previous year

Private new car sales take a dive in January

Consumer new car purchases fell by just under 14% compared to the same month a year ago, according to data published this week.

More from The Car Expert

Expert Advice

Award-winning, independent and impartial advice on buying, financing, owning and running a car

Expert Ratings

We analyse and aggregate dozens of media reviews for each new car into an overall Expert Rating

Expert News

All the most important new car launches, model updates, car reviews and industry news

Expert Partners

Our new space for commercial partners to bring you special offers on their products and services

What are your thoughts? Let us know below.