“Do you have to have your car serviced by a dealership to keep your new car warranty?” Asked by reader Dave Thompson.
There is considerable confusion among car owners about their servicing requirements, especially regarding what is required for them to maintain their new car warranty. We get asked this question a lot in our forum and in general conversation.
Dave says: “I just bought a new BMW and the salesman told me I have to have it serviced by a BMW dealership to maintain the new car warranty. Is this correct? I have seen businesses claiming they can service my car without affecting the warranty.”
The short answer is that, for warranty purposes, you don’t have to have your car serviced by a franchised dealership. However, that may affect your car finance agreement. Let’s explore those two points in more detail.
Servicing and your new car warranty
Assuming the above comment from Dave is an accurate portrayal of what was said, the BMW salesman has been very naughty here. EU legislation requires all car manufacturers to offer a minimum two-year unlimited mileage new car warranty on all their new cars (from date of registration), regardless of any change of ownership.
Under EU Block Exemption legislation, which has been around for many years now, a manufacturer cannot force a buyer to have their car serviced by their official dealership network, and cannot refuse to honour a new car warranty simply because a car has been serviced elsewhere. However, a manufacturer does have the right to set a servicing schedule which must be adhered to.
Cars outside their original new car warranty are a different kettle of fish altogether, and not covered here.
Once the UK leaves the EU, there is a remote possibility that a British government could eventually overturn this Block Exemption, but it is unlikely to ever happen. Not only will it not be a priority anytime soon, but local consumer groups would fiercely resist any attempts by manufacturer interests to compel British car owners to go to franchised dealers for servicing.
Many manufacturers offer new car warranty terms that are longer than the minimum two-year period, but you need to check that the warranty provider is the same for the whole warranty period. Some importers offer a longer period, but after two years the warranty is provided by the local importer rather than the vehicle manufacturer, so the terms and conditions may be different.
New car warranty and servicing – your rights and responsibilities
As a car owner, you have the right to take your car to any licenced garage or mechanic for servicing, but you must ensure that the servicing is carried out exactly as per the manufacturer’s servicing schedule.
This means servicing must be undertaken on time and must use any genuine parts or lubricants specified by the manufacturer.
If you choose to have your car serviced by an independent garage or mechanic, make sure they are reputable. For some suggestions, check out The Good Garage Scheme. Keep detailed invoices and receipts for all work done so you have proof that the car has been serviced according to schedule.
If your car requires repair work under its new car warranty, the manufacturer has the right to insist that this work is undertaken by its official dealerships. This is entirely fair, since the manufacturer – rather than you – is paying for this work.
Basically, a good rule to remember is that if you’re paying for the work, you have the right to choose who does the work.
What if it’s not a manufacturer’s new car warranty?
Not all warranties are provided by the vehicle manufacturer, and here you need to be careful.
Many dealers will offer you extended warranties for a new car, or a used car warranty of some description, but these are usually not provided by the manufacturer and are basically aftermarket insurance policies. As such, the requirements may be different and may tie you to a particular dealer or franchise for servicing.
What about my car finance obligations?
It is important to understand that although your new car warranty will not be affected if you service your car outside the dealer network, it may affect your car finance agreement.
Many PCP agreements will insist that the car has to be serviced by an approved franchised workshop to maintain the guaranteed future value (GFV) if you want to give the car back at the end of the agreement, and if you have a lease then you will also be expected to service the car with a dealership.
This isn’t a warranty issue but rather a question used car value. In theory, a car with a full manufacturer service history will be worth more than a car that’s been serviced at an independent garage, and the GFV is based on a car with a full manufacturer service history.
For more detailed information on this, have a read of our article about how a PCP can affect your servicing requirements.
Although not a legal requirement, it may be advantageous for you to take your car to a franchised dealer for servicing, depending on your car and your circumstances.
For more information on car servicing, read more about the difference between independent garages and franchised dealers.
This article was originally published in September 2012 and most recently updated with additional information in January 2019.