Should I repair my car’s damage or pocket the cash?

- Advertisement -

This article is brought to you by Your Car Credit.

If you’re like the vast majority of automobile owners, there will come a point where your vehicle is damaged in an accident. These can range from a minor fender-bender to a total loss of the vehicle, but the majority of cases wind up being rather small in nature.

Your insurance company will provide a determined amount of money for repairs whenever you file a claim – technically, you do not have to use the money provided to repair the vehicle. Because finances can often be tight and there are times where replacing the vehicle might be a better idea, many people wonder whether they should have the repairs performed, continue driving the vehicle as-is or procure a new one altogether. Below, we’ll attempt to shed light on the choices you have so that you can make the right decision.

Advantages of repairing

Car repair may be the best optionIf you plan to keep the vehicle for a while, then repairing it may be in your best interest. Especially true if functionality is impaired, the money that the insurance company will provide ensures that your vehicle can be brought back into working order.

The lack of repairs can decrease the value and resale potential of your automobile as time goes on, so newer vehicles – regardless of whether you plan to keep it or not – should be repaired to protect this aspect. Your mind will also rest easy in knowing that any damage sustained has been repaired and that no further complications will arise from the damage in the future.

Advantages of not repairing

Minor car damage may not be worth repairingIf the damage is minor and not compromising in any way the day-to-day operation of the vehicle, then pocketing the cash from the claim can come in handy. There are obviously a number of things you could do with this cash: you could save it for a later date, spend it on some other task that you’ve been putting off or even (not recommended) go on a shopping spree.

Many people struggle from paycheque to paycheque, however, which means that you probably need to catch up on bills if you’re considering this angle. A small crack in the fender or scratches in the paint don’t significantly impact performance or resale value, so this too is something to consider.

Advantages of financing a new vehicle

When faced with damage to your vehicle and a potential cash infusion, you may be thinking it’s time to trade in the vehicle for a new one. With the car still running and cash in hand, you can decide that trading the car in today and using the claims money as an additional down payment may be the best solution. If your car is older, then you don’t want to sink a lot of money into it – it may be time to bite the bullet, trade it in and finance a new one. Depending on the extent of the damage, you may have enough on-hand to make a hefty down payment on a new ride. Remember: the more you can pay down at the beginning, the less the new car will cost over time.  With lower interest rates these days, it has never been more affordable to finance a vehicle through the right lenders.

The decision to repair the vehicle or pocket the difference will depend on your personal circumstances. If you have an older vehicle and the damage isn’t severe, then you’re probably better off pocketing the cash or trading the vehicle in for a new one. If the damage is more severe, the car is newer or you still owe on it, then it’s generally a better idea to have the repairs performed. With this information, you can be sure to make the right decision in any of these situations.

- Advertisement -
Your Car Credit
This article was provided by Your Car Credit, providers of car finance for people with bad credit and quality used cars.

Latest Expert Advice

Christmas bargains for clever car buyers

As another year winds down, many car dealers are getting nervous. if you're in the market to buy, you could get a great new car deal this Christmas.

Petrol, hybrid or electric: what gets you motoring?

As we set course for banning new petrol and diesel cars by 2030, what are your power choices for buying a new car right now?

Latest Expert Ratings

Mazda 2

The Mazda 2 has received generally positive media reviews, although it's no longer considered to rank among the best in its class.

Volvo S60

The Volvo S60 has received widespread praise for its design and outstanding safety. However, it doesn't drive as nicely as a BMW 3 Series.

Jaguar E-Pace updated with new hybrid powertrains

Jaguar has given its compact E-Pace SUV a mid-life refresh, bringing a range of new hybrid powertrains as well as a variety of updates.

Fiat confirms pricing and specification for electric 500

The new electric Fiat 500 will cost from £19,995 (after the plug-in car grant) when it goes on sale in the UK early next year.

Regulator confims new coronavirus car finance measures

The Financial Conduct Authority has set out new car finance measures to help borrowers affected by the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.

Banning petrol and diesel cars: what does it mean?

The UK government has announced that new petrol and diesel car sales will end from 2030. Here's what you need to know.

More from The Car Expert

Expert Advice

Award-winning, independent and impartial advice on buying, financing, owning and running a car

Expert Ratings

We analyse and aggregate dozens of media reviews for each new car into an overall Expert Rating

Expert News

All the most important new car launches, model updates, car reviews and industry news

Expert Partners

Our new space for commercial partners to bring you special offers on their products and services


  1. A great blog! But it totally depends on the condition of your car… if it has a major damage then either go for claiming or else switch to new one…if you feel its not repairable.

What are your thoughts? Let us know below.