Highways England admits smart motorways are too confusing

Chief executive says drivers are confused about when they can use the hard shoulder and when it is closed to non-emergency traffic.

- Advertisement -

Smart motorways with a hard shoulder that is only used at busy times are “too complicated for people to use”, the boss of Highways England has admitted.

Chief executive Jim O’Sullivan told MPs that it will not build any more of what it calls “dynamic” smart motorways, where the hard should lane is open at selected times, because too many motorists do not understand them.

Smart motorways of this mature are already in use on certain sections of the M1, M4, M5, M6, M42 and M62 motorways. On other smart motorways, the hard shoulder is always open as a running lane unless there is an incident that requires it to be closed.

Mr O’Sullivan said drivers are confused about when they can use the hard shoulder and when it is closed to non-emergency traffic.

He explained to the Commons’ Transport Select Committee that some hard shoulders on dynamic smart motorways are only open to running traffic during the morning and evening peaks, but this catches out some drivers when their routine changes.

“People whose normal daily commute takes place at 8am or 9am, if they’ve been to the dentist and come out at 11am they drive down the hard shoulder,” he said.

“When we close it at other times of the day, people still drive down it.”

Mr O’Sullivan said there is confusion over when the hard shoulder is and is not open to traffic.

“We get people who stop there when it’s a running lane,” he told the committee.

“What we also find is because people aren’t sure if it’s a hard shoulder or a running lane, even when it is open, the usage of that running lane is much lower because people aren’t sure whether it’s a hard shoulder or not.”

He added: “I don’t think we will be building any more dynamic hard shoulder smart motorways. They’re just too complicated for people to use.”

Other types of smart motorways include all lane running schemes where lane one – formerly the hard shoulder – is only closed in the event of an accident, and controlled motorways which have variable speed limits but retain the hard shoulder for emergencies.

Smart motorways red X sign | The Car Expert

Smart motorways continue to cause controversy

Smart motorways have been developed as a way of increasing capacity and reducing congestion without the more costly process of widening roads.

There are growing concerns that the removal of a permanent hard shoulder has created a safety hazard, with some drivers being killed after stopping in live running lanes.

In March, an 83-year-old man was killed when his car was hit after it stopped in the fast lane on a section of the M1 in Derbyshire converted to a smart motorway.

This came months after a woman was killed on the same stretch of road after leaving a broken down car.

But Mr O’Sullivan insisted that smart motorways are “as safe or safer than conventional motorways”.

He added: “I would prefer to break down in the live lane of a managed motorway or a smart motorway than I would prefer to break down on a live lane on a conventional motorway or on a dual carriageway.”

Steve Gooding, director of motoring research charity the RAC Foundation, told the PA news agency: “The rules, regulations and layouts of roads should be easy to comprehend whether people are driving along them at 70mph or 7mph.

“The simpler motorways are to understand the safer they will be, as motorists concentrate on the hazards ahead rather than grappling with which lanes are available to them and which are not.”

- Advertisement -
Stuart Masson
Stuart Massonhttps://www.thecarexpert.co.uk/
Stuart is the Editorial Director of our suite of sites: The Car Expert, The Van Expert and The Truck Expert. Originally from Australia, Stuart has had a passion for cars and the automotive industry for over thirty years. He spent a decade in automotive retail, and now works tirelessly to help car buyers by providing independent and impartial advice.

Latest Expert Advice

Coronavirus and your car: Your questions answered

Updated car ownership, car maintenence and car finance guidance related to the coronavirus pandemic, provided by The Motor Ombudsman and The Car Expert.

Coronavirus: What precautions should I take if I need to fill up with fuel?

Although travel is discouraged, you may still need to fill up your car with fuel at some point. So how do you make sure you’re as safe as possible?

Latest Expert Ratings

Mazda CX-30

The Mazda CX-30 has received positive media reviews, with praise for its driving dynamics and interior quality but criticism for its small boot and cabin.

Citroën C1

The Citroën C1 has received generally positive media reviews, mainly for its low running costs, but is now dated and off the pace of newer city car rivals.

Honda Civic Type R Limited Edition sold out before customers even saw it

The low-volume Honda Civic Type R Limited Edition sold out in the UK before buyers even had a chance to see it or find out how much it would cost.

New Kia Sorento steps up its game

The all-new Kia Sorento is set to arrive in the UK later this year, initially as a petrol-electric hybrid or a diesel, with a plug-in hybrid set to follow.

BMW rolls out mild hybrid 3 Series, X3 and X4 models

BMW is expanding its range of mild hybrid-equipped vehicles to include the 3 Series saloon and estate, X3 SUV and X4 SUV models.

UK demand drives Lexus to 250,000 hybrid SUV sales in Europe

Lexus has now sold more than a quarter of a million hybrid SUVs, and says demand has been driven from the UK, which takes more than 25% of sales.

More from The Car Expert

Expert Advice

Award-winning, independent and impartial advice on buying, financing, owning and running a car

Expert Ratings

We analyse and aggregate dozens of media reviews for each new car into an overall Expert Rating

Expert News

All the most important new car launches, model updates, car reviews and industry news

Expert Partners

Our new space for commercial partners to bring you special offers on their products and services

What are your thoughts? Let us know below.